Antique and Collectable Firearms and Militaria Headquarters



Questions And Answers Page

If you have a question about firearms and you want it posted on this page click here.

Return to Collectors Headquarters.

Click here to go to the question and answer monthly index.

Click here to go to the question and answer subject index.

# 15157 - Shooting A Commemorative
Tom Rochelle, IL

Winchester - 94 Canadian Centennial - 30-30 - Long Octagon - Blue -

factory engraved receiver How much will shooting this firearm reduce its value?

Tom - I have never liked commemoratives much, but anyone with one is wise not to fire it and to save the box and original papers. For a commemorative to have any value over a regular model, it must be in 100% new condition, never have been fired, and have it's original box and papers. If you do not have the original box and papers you can deduct $100 to $150 from the value. If a commemorative has been fired or shows any signs of wear, it is just a ''fancy shooter'', worth little more (or maybe even less) than the same model that is not a commemorative. I would advise you to check and carefully clean and oil your commemorative periodically. I know someone who bought a new commemorative and left it for years in its original box without ever looking at it. When the box was opened, he found that the gun had acquired a fine coating of rust. Never cock or dry fire a commemorative. Marc

# 15065 - Sharps Model 1874 “Old Reliable” Target
Dave, Chardon, Ohio

1874 Sharps ''Old Reliable'' - 1874 Sharps Rifle - .45 - 10 - 29 - /4'' - Blue - 162189 -

Pistol grip, double set triggers, checkered, Vernier Sight, Tang sight, globe, level front sight, heavy barrel I received this gun from my father-in-law a few years ago and it has been in his family since the late 1800`s. The story that was told from long ago was that this gun was picked up off the battlefield of Little Big Horn. I don't know if this is even possible but it has always been the story. I am trying to find out more info on this gun as I am coming up on dead ends and would like to know if you may be able to uncover more about this gun. There is no ''invoice'' from the Sharps Company records as confirmed by Dr. Lebowski (?) from New York so it just adds to the mystery. Please let me know if you can find any new info. Thank You, Dave

Dave- The photos you sent help a lot, and I ran those by a friend who is one of the leading Sharps collectors, and his comments were: br>
“Dick [Labowski] was right, the gun has no shipping information. Not uncommon. However, it is in the last portion of guns made with a hammer, mid to late 1878. Company quit making 74s soon thereafter and only made 1878 Borchardt models until they closed in 1881. A Bridgeport gun, since Hartfords were only made through 1875. Almost all 1874 guns sold in this period were wholesaled in batches to various parts of the country. They were closing down the 74 production and cleaning out the inventory. This was made as a "target" style gun with the spirit level front sight and the long range tang sight, along with the serial number placement for the tang. (Meaning the gun was finished for use of a tang sight). Being 45 2 7/8" it was probably sold/made for a long range hunter as it is way too big for target work. Someone bought this to shoot large game at a distance. Undoubtedly went west somewhere. Probably spent a lot of time on a horse or in a wagon as it is too heavy to carry. NOT fun to shoot for everyday. Tired, but not abused condition which normally means a serious user/hunter. Did not care about the outside, but took care of the inside. Remember, these were tools at the time, not play things. Too late for the buffalo, unless in Montana or Canada, and then at the end. A fair number of these late guns were bought for hunters because they were then cheap and still large calibers (unlike Winchesters). Value might be somewhere in the $5,000-8,000 range. Sights are worth about $2,000 alone, gun is about $4-5K, but loses value IF sights are sold alone. Sights are rarer than the guns because sights became lost, broken, etc. and most guns survived. Anything closer to value would depend on examining the gun in person.”

I cannot add anything to what he said, other than it is almost certain that this was shipped too late for any possible Custer campaign use. John Spangler

# 15063 - Colt SAA History Dead End
Robert, Boerne, Texas

1882 Colt - Single Action Army - 44 - 4 3/4'' - Nickel - 82593 -

I recently purchased this revolver and received documentation from Colt Mfg that it was shipped to Shoverling, Daly, and Gales. Can you recommend someone I can talk with to find out more information on this pistol regarding its purchase history?

Robert- Unfortunately, not all leads can be followed up to another level. I am afraid you are at the end of the trail on this one.

Here is some information from html/company-S/Schoverling%20and%20Daly/Schoverling%20and%20Daly.html on Schoverling, Daly, and Gales:

The company started in 1865 and operated until 1873 as Schoverling and Daly, and in 1873 Gales was added and they continued in operation from 1865 to 1939. They were located at 302-304 Broadway in New York City, about two blocks from Francis Bannerman’s famous store at 501 Broadway.

They (S, D & G) had the Ballard patent rights and arranged with John M. Marlin to work over the patents and begin production in his plant. The first gun was made in 1875. Until 1891 more than 20 different models of the Ballard single shot rifle were offered. They were importers and distributors of guns and sporting goods. In 1875 they imported high end side by side shotguns under the name of Charles Daly. These shotguns were mainly European imports from Tolly of England, Newmann of Belgium Schiller and Charles Linder of Prussia and Lefever Arms Co. of New York. Henry Modell bought the company in 1919 and sold it to the Walzer family in the late 1920s.

Perhaps their records survive somewhere, but I doubt it and if they do, I have no idea where they might be. John Spangler

# 15155 - Model B In Need Of Parts
Ron Sumrall MS USA

O.F Mossburg And Sons Inc - Model B - .22 Cal - Look Like A Thirty - Other - DON'T NO WHERE IT FOUND -

Model B New Haven conn 22 LS & LR single shot bolt action. First time see one so I bought it. Where is serial number located? I would like to no more about. It look like a youth gun, and where can I find a bolt action assembly ?


Ron, your Mossberg probably does not have a serial number, it is pretty common for inexpensive guns manufactured before the late 1960s to not have one. References indicate that the Mossberg B was manufactured from 1930 to 1932, prior to 1968 there was no requirement for manufacturers to put serial numbers on their guns, so some did, and some did not.

For a parts source, we recommend you check with Gun Parts Corp (the old Numrich Arms people) at the following URL:

Gun Parts Corp has just about everything. If that doesn't work, try posting it on our free "Wanted" page at the following URL:

Hope this helps. Marc

# 15100 - 8.25 Inch Broomhandle
ronald dent

MAUSER - 96C BROOMHANDLE - 9mm - 8 1/4 - Blue - 803782 -

IS the length of the BARREL 8 1/4 right.? for THIS GUN.

I just got out my "Red 9" Mauser C96 pistol usually referred to as "the Broom handle" and measured the barrel length. From the front of the bolt to the tip of the barrel was 5.5 inches. From the back of the ejection port it measures 7.5 inches.

I'm not an expert on all of the variations of C96 pistols, but I've never seen an original with as long a barrel as you describe. The barrel of the C96 pistol is part of the forging that includes the rear end of the upper frame, and because of this cannot be replaced by screwing in a new barrel. There were several gunsmiths in the 1980's and 1990's who set up restoration services for the glut of Chinese import Broom Handle pistols that were on the market at the time. They would cut off shot out barrels, leaving a stub, then make a new barrel that screwed in to the stub at the base of the barrel. If I remember correctly, I think that FedOrd was doing this. I've seen two C96's where this was done. The workmanship one was so good it was extremely difficult to detect the newly made barrel was joined to the old frame. These guns were always re-chambered to 9 mm Luger.

A much longer than normal barrel makes me wonder if you do not have one that someone added an after market barrel. The fact that the gun is in 9mm and the serial number is not in the range of the "Red 9" pistols made for the German Army makes me think you have a pistol that has acquired a new barrel sometime after it left the factory. Marc

# 15061 - Jenks Breechloading Carbine Made By Remington
Gene, Brooklyn, NY 11209

Remington - Carbine ?? - 50 - 25 Inches - Other -

The markings on the top of the barrel ''W.Jenks'' over ''USN'' over ''RP'' over ''P'' over ''1847'' Marked ''Cast Steel'' Then side of the hammer mechanism is marked ''Remington's Herkimer NY'' Does it have any value?

Gene- Your description and the photos you sent confirm this is one of about 1,000 U.S. Navy breech loading Jenks carbines made by Remington in 1847-1848. These were the latest innovative arms of the time, with the Maynard tape primer mechanism, and a nearly unique “mule ear” side swinging percussion hammer. Really neat guns, but alas, your photos show that the gun is in poor to fair condition, and unfortunately missing several large and important parts of the breech mechanism. So, the neatness factor is totally eclipsed by the condition issues. Therefore, while it has some collector value, it is mainly for parts, or as an incomplete wall hanger, maybe a few hundred dollars at most. John Spangler

# 15150 - RIA 1911 Pistol Manufactured In 1943?
Ben, Dallas, Ga.

1911 - 45 - 5 In - Blue - RIA 1584724 -

I've been able to find out when it was made (1943), but not what it would be worth (ball park in good condition). Best guess?

Ben, I am afraid that I may have bad news. I can not say for sure without seeing the pistol, but there several aspects to your question that raise red flags. The first is that you indicate that your pistol is a 1911 but that it was manufactured in 1943. The U.S. military adopted the 1911A1 pistol 1920s, they were not purchasing any 1911 pistols in 1943. M1911A1 pistols should have serial numbers higher than 700,000 with lower serial numbers designated M1911. You indicate that your pistol has a blued finish but by 1943, all 1911A1 pistols had a Parkerized finish. Finally, if you check the serial number charts for 1911 and 1911A1 pistols at, you will see that no U.S. 1911 / A1 pistols ever had serial numbers that contain the letters "RIA".

These things lead me to believe that you have a modern production pistol that was manufactured by Armscor / Rock Island Armory. Values for modern Rock Island Armory pistols is in the $400 to $600 range depending on options, condition and the availability of a serious buyer. Marc

# 15059 - Winchester 94 Front Sight
Ronnie, Midlothian, VA

Winchester - 94 - 30-30 - 20'' - Blue - 1518471 -

It appears the front sight (which is ramped) is damaged to the point it needs to be replaced. the carbine was built in 1949 according to sources. I would like to know the height of the original sight. Was it a Winchester product or, as noted by Arthur Pirkle, a Lyman number 31 W Gold Bead. I note that Lyman no longer offers a sight by this product number. Thank you for your services. Ron Gray

Ronnie- I do not know enough about the subtle variations of the Winchester 94 to tell you anything. Art Pirkle, in addition to being the author of the excellent books on some of the Winchester models, is also a small dealer in Winchester parts. I recommend you try contacting him to see what he has. There are many other dealers selling parts, but I would start with Pirkle, and then maybe try Garry Fellers (see our links page) and then Google for other sources. John Spangler

# 15153 - Early Rusty Winchester in Mexico
Bill, Scottsdale, Arizona

Winchester - .30 WCR - .30 - Unknown - Rusty - 476566 -

I live in the Republic of Mexico and purchased this gun from a rancher a few years back. It is fully functional but in pretty rough shape. Just wondering if it is worth going through the hoops to import it into the U.S.

Bill, your Winchester was manufactured in 1910. If only some of these old guns could talk, what stories they might have to tell. We have run into many Model 94 Winchesters that are in rough condition like yours. When they were new, rifles like these were often purchased for use as a tool, to help put food on the table and for protection. They were not considered to be collectors items until many years later, and they saw allot of hard use when they were new.

The blue book sets values for standard Winchester Model 94 rifles in rough condition like yours between $500 and abut $650. I do not have an import license and I have never tried to bring a firearm into this country so I do not know what is involved in the process, but for me, that kind of value would not be enough motivation to spend much time or effort. You would probably be far better off to purchase a similar old rifle that is already in the U.S. Marc

# 15060 - Fayetteville 1864 Musket Value
ron, Dallas ga. USA

1864 Fayetteville Musket - 58 - Blue - NONE -

CSA marked buttplate, and all parts are intact. this piece is in good to very good condition according to the NRA antique grading guide. what is approx. value and how do I market it

ron- Although the Fayetteville made arms are very similar to U.S. Springfield models, there are a number of differences. Sadly, the differences are small enough that many purported CS Fayetteville arms have been faked over the years, sometimes innocently as “fillers” or for use by reenactors, but more often by larcenous SOBs intent on fleecing unsuspecting or uncurious buyers. Therefore, I view all such arms with great suspicion. And, since I do not know all there is to know about them, I generally stay away from them entirely. As far as value, that depends on: first, being an original Fayetteville made product, and then the current condition. There is a strong demand for just about anything which is (or is claimed to be) Confederate, and values are often high to really high. Probably the best way to get maximum price for it is to put it in one of the major firearms auctions, not your local estate auction, or one of the internet sites, but a real live auction by folks who sell lots of high end collector guns. I like and trust Cowans in Cincinnati, OH, and Julia’s in Maine. Rock Island moves a lot of stuff and seems to do a good job for sellers, but I know at least two buyers who were not happy with how absentee bids were handled with that outfit. You can search for “CS Fayetteville auction” and see if you can find “prices realized” to see what comparable condition guns went for. Remember, however, the owner only gets the amount of the hammer price, less any commissions and fees, which can add up to quite a bit. Thus, you may actually end up with about the same amount as if you sold to a reputable dealer. Good luck! John Spangler

Return to Collectors Headquarters.